• Latest
Why does a programme offering loans to African farmers in exchange for their carbon offset credits remind the author so much of the extraction of natural resources during the colonial era? Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Opinion: Beware of new colonists bearing carbon offsets

29 Aug 2022
The upcoming Senegal summit is a follow-up to the 2015 inaugural edition during which the “Feed Africa” strategy for Agricultural Transformation (2016-2025) in Africa was proposed. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Food production summit to open in Senegal

18 Jan 2023
Tomato losses: Solar-powered cold storage technology is of prime significance in Africa’s efforts to cut post-harvest tomato losses and attain food security, as outlined in the African Union Malabo Declaration. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Tanzania’s tomato harvest goes to waste

16 Jan 2023
Contextually, an average cow yields about 10 kilograms of dung per day, which corresponds to 1 000 litre biogas, equivalent to 2.14 kWh (electricity) while 1 000 litres of biomethane equals 10 kWh. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Biogas: ‘Cow dung can keep the lights on in SA’

14 Jan 2023
The Maputo Port is one of a number of harbours on the continent undergoing a changes to ready it for expansion. Photo: Wikicommons Media/Supplied

‘Ports race’ in Africa cuts both ways

10 Jan 2023
Namibia's Popular Democratic Movement party has tabled a motion of insurance for farmers, that will compensate for the loss of livestock due to conflict with wildlife. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Computer model to ease farmer-wildlife conflict

5 Jan 2023
Mohamed Dhicis (19) started a beekeeping business in his hometown of Belet Weyne, in central Somalia. He is supported by an entrepreneurship develop programme of the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) in collaboration with the Somali Ministry of Commerce and Industries. Photo: Supplied/United Nations

Bees and tractors: Agri leads the way in Somalia

4 Jan 2023
It started with a handful of trees on her family farm. Today Wezi Mzumara is breaking new ground as a woman chocolate maker in Malawi. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Meet Malawian chocolate maker Wezi Mzumara

2 Jan 2023
“EOS_SAT-1 is already fueled, configured for launch and integrated onto the upper stage of the rocket, waiting for the last remaining thing ¬– launch.” This notice and picture was posted on the Twitter page of aerospace start-up Dragonfly Aerospace. Photo: Twitter

African agri satellite a world first

1 Jan 2023
Nature-based biopesticides are now offering a safer alternative to locust control. ©FAO/Ismail Taxta/Arete

Locusts: How Somalia became biopesticides leader

30 Dec 2022
Women attend a UNFPA-supported integrated community health outreach session on prevention and response to gender-based violence. Lokapararai village, Turkana county, Kenya. Photo: Supplied/UNFPA Kenya

Drought puts Kenyan newborns at risk

28 Dec 2022
Child labour has increased exponentially over the course of the past four years, according to UNICEF and ILO. Photo: Wikkimedia Commons

‘Children exploited’ on Malawi tobacco farms

23 Dec 2022
5 ways tech is transforming agrifood systems

5 ways tech is transforming agrifood systems

22 Dec 2022
NEWSLETTER SIGNUP!
Thu, Feb 2, 2023
No Result
View All Result
Food For Afrika
  • Home
  • Agri News
    • All
    • Agri Politics
    • Business
    • Development
    • Markets
    • Trade
    The upcoming Senegal summit is a follow-up to the 2015 inaugural edition during which the “Feed Africa” strategy for Agricultural Transformation (2016-2025) in Africa was proposed. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Food production summit to open in Senegal

    Tomato losses: Solar-powered cold storage technology is of prime significance in Africa’s efforts to cut post-harvest tomato losses and attain food security, as outlined in the African Union Malabo Declaration. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Tanzania’s tomato harvest goes to waste

    Contextually, an average cow yields about 10 kilograms of dung per day, which corresponds to 1 000 litre biogas, equivalent to 2.14 kWh (electricity) while 1 000 litres of biomethane equals 10 kWh. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Biogas: ‘Cow dung can keep the lights on in SA’

    The Maputo Port is one of a number of harbours on the continent undergoing a changes to ready it for expansion. Photo: Wikicommons Media/Supplied

    ‘Ports race’ in Africa cuts both ways

    Mohamed Dhicis (19) started a beekeeping business in his hometown of Belet Weyne, in central Somalia. He is supported by an entrepreneurship develop programme of the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) in collaboration with the Somali Ministry of Commerce and Industries. Photo: Supplied/United Nations

    Bees and tractors: Agri leads the way in Somalia

    “EOS_SAT-1 is already fueled, configured for launch and integrated onto the upper stage of the rocket, waiting for the last remaining thing ¬– launch.” This notice and picture was posted on the Twitter page of aerospace start-up Dragonfly Aerospace. Photo: Twitter

    African agri satellite a world first

    Women attend a UNFPA-supported integrated community health outreach session on prevention and response to gender-based violence. Lokapararai village, Turkana county, Kenya. Photo: Supplied/UNFPA Kenya

    Drought puts Kenyan newborns at risk

    Child labour has increased exponentially over the course of the past four years, according to UNICEF and ILO. Photo: Wikkimedia Commons

    ‘Children exploited’ on Malawi tobacco farms

    5 ways tech is transforming agrifood systems

    5 ways tech is transforming agrifood systems

  • Changemakers
    • All
    • Agribusiness
    • Agripreneurs
    • Farmers
    • Innovation
    Namibia's Popular Democratic Movement party has tabled a motion of insurance for farmers, that will compensate for the loss of livestock due to conflict with wildlife. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Computer model to ease farmer-wildlife conflict

    It started with a handful of trees on her family farm. Today Wezi Mzumara is breaking new ground as a woman chocolate maker in Malawi. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Meet Malawian chocolate maker Wezi Mzumara

    Nature-based biopesticides are now offering a safer alternative to locust control. ©FAO/Ismail Taxta/Arete

    Locusts: How Somalia became biopesticides leader

    The award-winning Nigerian farmer Samson Ogbole, who did not initially want to be a farmer, incorporates technology, science and agriculture to end hunger.

    Meet ‘Farmer Samson’, biochemist and soilless farmer

    What started as an informal Facebook group has become a vibrant online market community in East Africa called Mkulima Young.

    East Africa’s vibrant digital one-stop for farmers

    Greenify Global, a youth environmental conservation movement, works in schools in Zomba, Malawi, teaching children and creating food gardens according to permaculture principles. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Malawi permaculture project teaches earth care

    Woman Farmer Kerotse Lekabe (middle) with her workers in Pella, North West, where she farms with vegetables on six hectares of land. Photo- Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Woman farmer’s drive builds family business

    Support to improve women land ownership delivers life-changing benefits for women farmers in Tanzania, like Mariam Tungu, from Singida’s Ikungi district in central Tanzania. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Women land ownership changes destinies

    Planting his first crops was like throwing dice for Lesotho small-scale farmer Leutsoa Khobotlo. He felt like he won that game of chance. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Luck and dedication lifts Lesotho farmer

  • Food Security
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Crops
    • Food Trends
    • Logistics
    Climate change: A total of 27% of children in South Africa are stunted. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Climate change ‘a daily reality’ for Africans

    Cop27: Zambian farmer Esther Zulu was born in Nyimba district in the eastern part of Zambia. She currently lives and farms on property inherited from her parents, both of whom were farmers. Photo: Supplied/AICCRA

    Cop27: Zambian farmer demands food systems change

    With heavier and unpredictable rainfall and tides encroaching on coastal cities, the risk of flooding is becoming more prevalent. Through an FAO project, local communities in Quelimane, Mozambique have restored 1.6 hectares of mangroves to prevent flooding and soil erosion. Photo: Supplied/Mani Tese/Leonel Raimo

    Green city living changes Africa’s urban landscape

    Perennial rice being harvested near Lake Victoria in Uganda. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Perennial rice could boost food security in Africa

    The global FoodTech Challenge is looking to reward 4 agritech or foodtech companies working to address food security challenges. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    FoodTech Challenge: 3 African startups shortlisted

    30-year-old farmer Nerudo Mregi is transforming the face of farming by applying technology and artificial intelligence. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Welcome to agri’s future of drones, robots and IoT

    Farmer Japeth Owidi makes use of a solar-powered pump to ease the labour-intensive strain of farming. Photo: Supplied/FuturePump

    COP27: Small-scale farmers belong at the table

    Insect-rearing requires minimal access to land and feed, providing income and livelihood opportunities for many in rural and urban communities. Left/top: Photo: FAO/Giulio Napolitano

    World ‘worms’ up to edible insects

    Hunger and malnutrition in the Lake Chad Basin have reached alarming levels this year, driven by Boko Haram terrorism and the effects of climate change.

    Hunger, terrorism stalks Lake Chad Basin

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Food Health
    • Trends
    A picture featuring George Chiwedzerero, who left Zimbabwe for South Africa and was not heard from for two decades.

    Missing migrants project helps families find peace

    The general impression of Zanzibar when approached from the mainland is of a long, low island with small ridges along its central north–south axis. Coconut palms and other vegetation cover the land surface. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Here’s how farming transformed Zanzibar’s coastline

    Saponins also work against bacteria and fungi. Some bacteria have an external membrane that protects their genetic material. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Southern Africa’s soapy plants can improve hand hygiene

    There are a number of flowering plants that we do not often recognise the holistic health benefits of, such as okra, kalanchoe and periwinkle flowers. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Healing with the help of Africa’s indigenous plants

    Burger King is one of many fast food franchises that is introducing more plant-based meals. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Burger King, KFC explore more veggie options

    Cassava is one of the continent's food staples. Here is a history on the root veg and its humble beginnings. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Cassava, a staple crop that sustains a continent

    Herbal remedies are commonplace in Uganda; testing these scientifically is a good way to ensure they’re safe and effective. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Herbal skin treatments in Uganda get a scientific boost

    Researchers believe that Rwanda's soft drink tax can be better used to boost public health by targeting sugar content. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Sugar tax might curb rise in obesity, diabetes in Rwanda

    Lebanese farmers have shirked using chemicals during the goring process and are realising their produce is healthy regardless. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Lebanese potato farmers find that less is more

  • Home
  • Agri News
    • All
    • Agri Politics
    • Business
    • Development
    • Markets
    • Trade
    The upcoming Senegal summit is a follow-up to the 2015 inaugural edition during which the “Feed Africa” strategy for Agricultural Transformation (2016-2025) in Africa was proposed. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Food production summit to open in Senegal

    Tomato losses: Solar-powered cold storage technology is of prime significance in Africa’s efforts to cut post-harvest tomato losses and attain food security, as outlined in the African Union Malabo Declaration. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Tanzania’s tomato harvest goes to waste

    Contextually, an average cow yields about 10 kilograms of dung per day, which corresponds to 1 000 litre biogas, equivalent to 2.14 kWh (electricity) while 1 000 litres of biomethane equals 10 kWh. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Biogas: ‘Cow dung can keep the lights on in SA’

    The Maputo Port is one of a number of harbours on the continent undergoing a changes to ready it for expansion. Photo: Wikicommons Media/Supplied

    ‘Ports race’ in Africa cuts both ways

    Mohamed Dhicis (19) started a beekeeping business in his hometown of Belet Weyne, in central Somalia. He is supported by an entrepreneurship develop programme of the United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO) in collaboration with the Somali Ministry of Commerce and Industries. Photo: Supplied/United Nations

    Bees and tractors: Agri leads the way in Somalia

    “EOS_SAT-1 is already fueled, configured for launch and integrated onto the upper stage of the rocket, waiting for the last remaining thing ¬– launch.” This notice and picture was posted on the Twitter page of aerospace start-up Dragonfly Aerospace. Photo: Twitter

    African agri satellite a world first

    Women attend a UNFPA-supported integrated community health outreach session on prevention and response to gender-based violence. Lokapararai village, Turkana county, Kenya. Photo: Supplied/UNFPA Kenya

    Drought puts Kenyan newborns at risk

    Child labour has increased exponentially over the course of the past four years, according to UNICEF and ILO. Photo: Wikkimedia Commons

    ‘Children exploited’ on Malawi tobacco farms

    5 ways tech is transforming agrifood systems

    5 ways tech is transforming agrifood systems

  • Changemakers
    • All
    • Agribusiness
    • Agripreneurs
    • Farmers
    • Innovation
    Namibia's Popular Democratic Movement party has tabled a motion of insurance for farmers, that will compensate for the loss of livestock due to conflict with wildlife. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Computer model to ease farmer-wildlife conflict

    It started with a handful of trees on her family farm. Today Wezi Mzumara is breaking new ground as a woman chocolate maker in Malawi. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Meet Malawian chocolate maker Wezi Mzumara

    Nature-based biopesticides are now offering a safer alternative to locust control. ©FAO/Ismail Taxta/Arete

    Locusts: How Somalia became biopesticides leader

    The award-winning Nigerian farmer Samson Ogbole, who did not initially want to be a farmer, incorporates technology, science and agriculture to end hunger.

    Meet ‘Farmer Samson’, biochemist and soilless farmer

    What started as an informal Facebook group has become a vibrant online market community in East Africa called Mkulima Young.

    East Africa’s vibrant digital one-stop for farmers

    Greenify Global, a youth environmental conservation movement, works in schools in Zomba, Malawi, teaching children and creating food gardens according to permaculture principles. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Malawi permaculture project teaches earth care

    Woman Farmer Kerotse Lekabe (middle) with her workers in Pella, North West, where she farms with vegetables on six hectares of land. Photo- Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Woman farmer’s drive builds family business

    Support to improve women land ownership delivers life-changing benefits for women farmers in Tanzania, like Mariam Tungu, from Singida’s Ikungi district in central Tanzania. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Women land ownership changes destinies

    Planting his first crops was like throwing dice for Lesotho small-scale farmer Leutsoa Khobotlo. He felt like he won that game of chance. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Luck and dedication lifts Lesotho farmer

  • Food Security
    • All
    • Climate Change
    • Crops
    • Food Trends
    • Logistics
    Climate change: A total of 27% of children in South Africa are stunted. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Climate change ‘a daily reality’ for Africans

    Cop27: Zambian farmer Esther Zulu was born in Nyimba district in the eastern part of Zambia. She currently lives and farms on property inherited from her parents, both of whom were farmers. Photo: Supplied/AICCRA

    Cop27: Zambian farmer demands food systems change

    With heavier and unpredictable rainfall and tides encroaching on coastal cities, the risk of flooding is becoming more prevalent. Through an FAO project, local communities in Quelimane, Mozambique have restored 1.6 hectares of mangroves to prevent flooding and soil erosion. Photo: Supplied/Mani Tese/Leonel Raimo

    Green city living changes Africa’s urban landscape

    Perennial rice being harvested near Lake Victoria in Uganda. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Perennial rice could boost food security in Africa

    The global FoodTech Challenge is looking to reward 4 agritech or foodtech companies working to address food security challenges. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    FoodTech Challenge: 3 African startups shortlisted

    30-year-old farmer Nerudo Mregi is transforming the face of farming by applying technology and artificial intelligence. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Welcome to agri’s future of drones, robots and IoT

    Farmer Japeth Owidi makes use of a solar-powered pump to ease the labour-intensive strain of farming. Photo: Supplied/FuturePump

    COP27: Small-scale farmers belong at the table

    Insect-rearing requires minimal access to land and feed, providing income and livelihood opportunities for many in rural and urban communities. Left/top: Photo: FAO/Giulio Napolitano

    World ‘worms’ up to edible insects

    Hunger and malnutrition in the Lake Chad Basin have reached alarming levels this year, driven by Boko Haram terrorism and the effects of climate change.

    Hunger, terrorism stalks Lake Chad Basin

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Food Health
    • Trends
    A picture featuring George Chiwedzerero, who left Zimbabwe for South Africa and was not heard from for two decades.

    Missing migrants project helps families find peace

    The general impression of Zanzibar when approached from the mainland is of a long, low island with small ridges along its central north–south axis. Coconut palms and other vegetation cover the land surface. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Here’s how farming transformed Zanzibar’s coastline

    Saponins also work against bacteria and fungi. Some bacteria have an external membrane that protects their genetic material. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Southern Africa’s soapy plants can improve hand hygiene

    There are a number of flowering plants that we do not often recognise the holistic health benefits of, such as okra, kalanchoe and periwinkle flowers. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Healing with the help of Africa’s indigenous plants

    Burger King is one of many fast food franchises that is introducing more plant-based meals. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Burger King, KFC explore more veggie options

    Cassava is one of the continent's food staples. Here is a history on the root veg and its humble beginnings. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Cassava, a staple crop that sustains a continent

    Herbal remedies are commonplace in Uganda; testing these scientifically is a good way to ensure they’re safe and effective. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Herbal skin treatments in Uganda get a scientific boost

    Researchers believe that Rwanda's soft drink tax can be better used to boost public health by targeting sugar content. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Sugar tax might curb rise in obesity, diabetes in Rwanda

    Lebanese farmers have shirked using chemicals during the goring process and are realising their produce is healthy regardless. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

    Lebanese potato farmers find that less is more

No Result
View All Result
Food For Afrika
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

Opinion: Beware of new colonists bearing carbon offsets

by Carolien Samson
29 Aug 2022
in Climate Change
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
Why does a programme offering loans to African farmers in exchange for their carbon offset credits remind the author so much of the extraction of natural resources during the colonial era? Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Why does a programme offering loans to African farmers in exchange for their carbon offset credits remind the author so much of the extraction of natural resources during the colonial era? Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

On first glance, a new project to encourage and fund smallholders to practice agroforestry through providing them with loans and entry into the international carbon offset market, writes Carolien Samson. However, she points out, it hides major flaws.


Rabobank through its Rabo Foundation has announced that it will be offering smallholder farmers in Africa “carbon loans” to adopt sustainable and climate resilient agroforestry farming in partnership with a United Kingdom-supported NGO, FSD Africa.

ADVERTISEMENT

As the trees and crops grow, the biomass will be measured using remote sensing and “carbon removal units” will be sold to corporates via the Rabobank trading platform, Acorn. The offsets will be used by the farmers to repay the loans while surplus could be paid out in cash or as farm inputs. The project will initially launch in Kenya, Nigeria and Tanzania and aims to reach one million farmers across the globe.

At first glance, this sounded like an innovative idea when FoodForAfrika.com’s Kobus Louwrens highlighted it on LinkedIn to me. Except it hides major flaws.

ALSO READ: ‘Carbon loans’ offer win-win for climate, farmers

Removing carbon from the atmosphere and locking it into the soil is an important element of fighting climate change. Plants absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, convert it to sugars and store it in the soil until the soil is disturbed or the plant dies, when the carbon is released back into the atmosphere. Trees absorb lots of carbon through their leaves over the course of a lifetime and has other useful purposes like protecting biodiversity and providing food and shade.

In addition, Rabobank and its partners have invested and developed a comprehensive standard for smallholder carbon offset projects which is sorely needed. So, what is not to like about a project that will see more trees planted and more carbon stored in the soil through regenerative farming practices by smallholder farmers? The intention is laudable, and I fully support the concept of assisting these vulnerable farmers in countries which are at high risk to prepare for a hotter future, but I have fundamental issues with this format. 

Pressure to reach net zero

Companies and governments across the world are trying to reduce the impact of the carbon emissions of their activities in various ways. More than 3,000 companies are currently setting science-based targets to reach net zero emissions by 2050. Net zero doesn’t mean that the company won’t have any emissions, only that it would have found a way to store its emissions so that it will not reach the atmosphere.

Countries like the United Kingdom have developed legislation which compels the country to reach net zero. First prize would be for companies to reduce their own emissions to zero, but some industries will find this virtually impossible to do or will take a long time to reach it. Therefore, they are allowed to offset some of their emissions by paying someone else who has the ability to store on their behalf. 

To qualify as an offset the carbon must be stored permanently, there must be no leakage and the project must be additional to existing plans. The agroforestry projects proposed by Rabobank clearly meets the definition of additionality as they would not be occurring if it were not for the carbon offsets.

Leakage is always difficult to decide in agriculture and in this case defined by the fact that no grazing or food production activities will be moved elsewhere. Soil carbon by definition is never permanent. The project gets around this fact by clearly stating that their aim is to store the carbon for 20 years and then rename the offsets to “carbon removal units”. In practice this means that corporates that buy these would have to replace them in 20 years’ time, although this is mentioned nowhere in the documentation.

Who bears the risks?

This gets me to my first issue with the project. Smallholder farmer are being compelled to take up loan finance so that they can sequester carbon which allows large corporates to avoid reducing their emissions. In addition, the smallholder farmer is expected to carry both price and production risk until the trees reach a point where carbon can be sold.

A very attractive promise to corporates buying these offsets is that they already exist and is not based on a promise of future carbon. However, this skews the process significantly in favour of large corporates with buying power and access to the carbon market.

For example we could have an instance where the farmer incurs a debt to enter into agroforestry. Three years into the process a severe drought or a fire destroys the biomass created to date. The farmer has little resources to repay the debt or restart the operation, because all performance risk is carried at farm level.

Farmers will also have to take all price risk with little ability to choose instruments or consider alternatives.

Although the assumption is that carbon prices will increase over the long-term, there is no guarantee that farmers will be able to sell carbon at price levels that will repay the loan. The power imbalance in this relationship is stark. 

ADVERTISEMENT

If this project was undertaken without the loan component, it would be assisting vulnerable smallholder farmers to improve their farming practices and become more climate resilient. It would as a side-effect assist the world to remove some carbon from the atmosphere which is critical at this stage. Now however, these farmers are forced into debt with all the risk shifted onto the farmer. A structure which involves the parties like Rabobank and the corporates carrying price risk would address some of the concerns, but we are far from that point. 

ADVERTISEMENT

The issue of double-counting

One of the issues deeply debated under the Paris Agreement was how to stop double-counting of tonnes of carbon sequestrated. The challenge is to decide where the carbon sequestrated in one country and traded with an entity in another country will be recognised.

Under the Paris Agreement all countries have agreed to reduce their carbon emissions by implementing nationally determined contributions (NCDs). Article 6 of the Agreement allows countries to cooperate to reach their climate goals. Countries with low emissions or good capacity to store carbon could trade emissions with other countries through bi-lateral agreements or in future projects, could be registered with a UN supervisory body. 

This project standard makes it quite clear that the countries selected to undertake these projects are not chosen accidently, but deliberately targeted those with no formal legislation that will prevent the smallholder farmers from trading their carbon rights.

The Rabobank project is going to lend money to smallholder farmers who will capture carbon in their countries which could be contributing to their own countries’ NCDs and then sell it to global corporates to repay the loans. This ignores the legal risk carried by the project that legislation could change in either the country of origin or purchase at some point in time that would prohibit these sales which would again leave the farmer exposed with debt, but potentially no market. Why does this remind me so much of the resource exploitation that Africa has been subject to for centuries? 

Let’s be clear. Smallholder farmers in Africa are extremely vulnerable to the effects of climate change and can contribute to removing excess emissions through agroforestry practices. They should receive assistance to adapt their practices and become more resilient in a world where extreme weather events will affect them disproportionately. They should absolutely not be forced to use loans to do this which allows multinational banks to generate profits through carbon trading and large corporates to avoid reducing their emissions.

Projects such as these which have the appearance of providing innovative financing solutions, but which exploit the balance of power between large banks and corporates and vulnerable farmers will contribute to a loss of confidence in these solutions to the detriment of those who need them most.  

Carolien Samson is Head of Sustainable Banking at Oxbury Bank. This article reflects the author’s personal views and does not represent those of her employer in any way whatsoever.

Tags: AgroforestryCarbon offsetsClimate Change
Carolien Samson

Carolien Samson

Carolien Samson is Head of Sustainable Banking at Oxbury Bank. The opinions she expresses in her writing does not represent those of her employer in any way.

Next Post
Dr. Nawal Benaissa, founder and CEO of Greenal, developed a faster, more efficient technology for turning organic waste into biogas. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

From camel dung to a high-tech energy solution

The upcoming Senegal summit is a follow-up to the 2015 inaugural edition during which the “Feed Africa” strategy for Agricultural Transformation (2016-2025) in Africa was proposed. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com
Agri News

Food production summit to open in Senegal

by Staff Reporter
18 Jan 2023
0

African heads of state and government together with development partners will gather in Senegal to strategically map plans to unlock...

Read more
Tomato losses: Solar-powered cold storage technology is of prime significance in Africa’s efforts to cut post-harvest tomato losses and attain food security, as outlined in the African Union Malabo Declaration. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Tanzania’s tomato harvest goes to waste

16 Jan 2023
Contextually, an average cow yields about 10 kilograms of dung per day, which corresponds to 1 000 litre biogas, equivalent to 2.14 kWh (electricity) while 1 000 litres of biomethane equals 10 kWh. Photo: Supplied/FoodForAfrika.com

Biogas: ‘Cow dung can keep the lights on in SA’

14 Jan 2023
The Maputo Port is one of a number of harbours on the continent undergoing a changes to ready it for expansion. Photo: Wikicommons Media/Supplied

‘Ports race’ in Africa cuts both ways

10 Jan 2023
Namibia's Popular Democratic Movement party has tabled a motion of insurance for farmers, that will compensate for the loss of livestock due to conflict with wildlife. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Computer model to ease farmer-wildlife conflict

5 Jan 2023

Food production summit to open in Senegal

Tanzania’s tomato harvest goes to waste

Biogas: ‘Cow dung can keep the lights on in SA’

‘Ports race’ in Africa cuts both ways

Computer model to ease farmer-wildlife conflict

Bees and tractors: Agri leads the way in Somalia

Food For Afrika

African farmers and agripreneurs, rise up. FoodForAfrika.com is a continent-wide agriculture publication celebrating sustainable agriculture. We salute the agriculturists who bring food to our tables.

Categories

  • Agri News
  • Agri Politics
  • Agribusiness
  • Agripreneurs
  • Business
  • Changemakers
  • Climate Change
  • Crops
  • Development
  • Farmers
  • Food Health
  • Food Security
  • Food Trends
  • Innovation
  • Lifestyle
  • Logistics
  • Markets
  • Premium
  • Trade
  • Trends
  • Uncategorised

Contact Us

Office: +27 21 879 1824
News: info@foodforafrika.com
Advertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za

Follow Us

  • Home
  • Food Security
  • Agri News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle

© 2022 Farmers For Change Pty (Ltd)

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Food Security
  • Agri News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle

© 2022 Farmers For Change Pty (Ltd)